Boxing vs F45
F45 Training has exploded across London with its franchise model, 45-minute classes, and TV-screen-guided workouts. It is slick, social, and very expensive. Boxing is older, cheaper, and teaches you something you will actually keep. Here is the honest comparison.
The Core Difference
Boxing
A skill-based discipline with centuries of history. You learn to punch, move, and defend. Every session builds on the last.
- • Technique-based: jab, cross, hook, uppercut
- • Coach-led with personal feedback
- • Progressive skill development
- • Community gym culture
- • £5-£10 per session, no contracts
F45 Training
A franchise group fitness concept. 45-minute classes follow screens showing exercises. High variety, high energy, high price.
- • Exercise-based: varied daily workouts
- • Screen-guided with trainers assisting
- • Variety over depth
- • Boutique fitness culture
- • £185-£225/month unlimited in London
F45 is a franchise. Every studio follows the same centrally programmed workouts, displayed on screens. The trainers are there to assist, not to teach you a skill. This is fundamentally different from boxing, where a coach watches your technique, corrects your form, and progressively develops your ability over months and years. At Honour and Glory, our ABA-affiliated coaches work with you individually from your very first session.
As one Reddit user in r/f45 noted when weighing up their options: the value question comes down to whether you need someone else to programme your workouts, or whether you want to learn something that develops independently of a subscription.
Cost: The Unavoidable Gap
F45 London pricing from studio websites, 2026. H&G pay-per-session, no joining fee.
The maths is stark. F45 unlimited in London costs £2,220-£2,700 per year. Boxing at Honour and Glory three times a week costs approximately £1,440 per year. That is a difference of £780-£1,260 annually. For that saving, you could buy premium boxing gloves, a full set of hand wraps, and still have enough left for a weekend away.
F45 also typically requires a contract. Boxing at a community club is pay-as-you-go. If you go on holiday for two weeks, you do not pay for two weeks. Try that with an F45 membership.
Skill Development vs Workout Variety
This is the fundamental trade-off. F45 gives you a different workout every day. Monday might be cardio-focused, Tuesday is resistance, Wednesday is a hybrid. The variety prevents boredom, and for people who struggle to programme their own training, it removes all decision-making.
But variety comes at the cost of depth. After a year of F45, you have done hundreds of different exercises but mastered none of them. After a year of boxing, you have developed real technique, real timing, and real defensive awareness. You have learned a skill that stays with you for life, even if you stop training for years.
The skill element is also what makes boxing sustainable long-term. F45 workouts are intense, but they are just exercise. When the novelty fades, there is no deeper engagement to sustain motivation. Boxing deepens over time. The better you get, the more interesting it becomes.
Community
F45 builds community through shared classes and the social atmosphere of boutique fitness. It works. The high-fives, the team challenges, and the post-workout selfies create a sense of belonging. Credit where it is due.
Boxing builds community differently. It tends to be less performative, more intergenerational, and rooted in local identity. At Honour and Glory in Kidbrooke, you will find 5-year-olds training alongside retirees, office workers alongside tradespeople. The shared challenge of learning a difficult skill creates bonds that go deeper than a shared HIIT circuit.
There is also a question of accessibility. F45 communities tend to draw from a narrow demographic: young professionals with disposable income. Boxing gyms draw from everyone. That diversity is part of what makes the community valuable.
Fitness Results: What the Data Says
Head-to-Head Comparison
F45 sessions are 45 minutes. Boxing sessions at a community club typically run 60-90 minutes. Minute for minute, boxing burns slightly more calories because of the higher sustained heart rate and full-body engagement of punching. But F45's shorter format suits people with tight schedules.
Both develop cardiovascular fitness effectively. Where they differ is body composition. Boxing develops the characteristic lean, defined upper body (shoulders, arms, core) through thousands of repetitive, explosive movements. F45 develops more general fitness through varied exercises that change daily. The F45 approach prevents boredom but also prevents the specific adaptations that come from repeated, focused training. For more on the calorie comparison, see How Many Calories Does Boxing Burn?
The Five-Year Question
Ask yourself where each activity leaves you in five years. After five years of F45, you have done approximately 780 classes (3x/week) of varied workouts. You are fit. You have spent roughly £12,000. But you have no specific skill to show for it. If F45 closes or you move to an area without a studio, you need to find something new from scratch.
After five years of boxing, you can box. You have a genuine combat skill. You can throw combinations, move defensively, and handle yourself with confidence. You can train at any boxing gym in the world, in any country, and fit right in. You have spent roughly £7,200 and the skill travels with you forever.
This is the fundamental difference between a fitness product and a fitness discipline. Products require ongoing subscription. Disciplines become part of who you are.
Rate this article
Your feedback helps us write better content
The Verdict
Choose boxing if:
- • You want to learn a genuine, lasting skill
- • You prefer pay-as-you-go with no contracts
- • You value depth over variety
- • You want a diverse, intergenerational community
- • Saving £800+ per year matters to you
Choose F45 if:
- • You want maximum workout variety daily
- • You prefer screen-guided, structured sessions
- • You enjoy the boutique fitness social scene
- • Budget is not a primary concern
- • You struggle to motivate without novelty
Our honest take: F45 is a well-executed fitness product. But it is a product, not a discipline. Boxing teaches you something real, costs a fraction of the price, and creates a community that spans every demographic. If you want to get fit and learn nothing, F45 will do the job. If you want to get fit and become something, try boxing. Want to see for yourself? Book a free session and find out.
See also: Boxing vs HIIT | Boxing vs CrossFit | Is Boxing Worth It? | Boxing vs HYROX | Boxing vs Orangetheory | Boxing vs Barry's Bootcamp
The best way to decide? Come and try it.
Your first session is free. No contract, no commitment.
Book Your Free Boxing Session
Your first session is free. No contract, no joining fee, no catches.
📍 122 Broad Walk, SE3 8ND · Pay as you go from £5